Score Breakdown
Critical Issues
Priority: Immediate Action
Business Category Undefined
This limits discoverability and reduces the likelihood of being recommended to the right audience on Instagram.
High Number of Highlights
With 82 highlights, vital information can get lost, making it overwhelming for new visitors to navigate.
Limited Engagement on Some Posts
Posts like "Bestselling coasters" only received 10 likes and no comments, indicating either a content mismatch or ineffective engagement strategy.
Opportunities
Priority: Quick Wins
Consolidate Highlights
Reduce the number of highlights to 5-10, focusing on key areas like Portfolio, Services, Testimonials, About, and FAQs to streamline user experience.
Optimize Business Category
Set a specific business category like "Visual Artist" or "Fine Art" to improve targeting accuracy in Instagram’s algorithms.
Utilize Name Field
Change `fullName` to include a keyword: "John | NYC Whimsical Artist" to enhance searchability.
Optimized Bio Options
Option 1: Collectors/High-End Clients Focus
101/150
Why it works:
- • This bio speaks directly to high-end clients by mentioning the artist's location, niche, and an easy contact method, establishing credibility and availability for commissions.
Option 2: Volume/Bookings Focus
116/150
Why it works:
- • This variation uses clear CTAs and contact information to attract bookings, emphasizing the artist's specialty and city influence.
Option 3: Community/Growth Focus
103/150
Why it works:
- • It leverages community-focused language to engage local followers, fostering a sense of community involvement and encouraging event participation.
Current vs. Recommended
Character Usage
📊Name Field
✨Business Category
✨Highlight Count
✨CTA in Bio
✨Social Proof
✨Competitive Intelligence
Top Related Accounts Analysis:
- Most common bio elements: Successful profiles often include clear descriptors like "NYC Artist" or "Pet Portrait Specialist," which are missing in Johnnerdraws' current bio.
- Link strategies: Some top performers use individual links per platform rather than a link-in-bio service for direct traffic routing.
- Highlight structures: Competitors with fewer highlights tend to have higher engagement, focusing on 5-7 key categories.
- Opportunities to differentiate: Johnnerdraws can emphasize his dual focus on whimsical art and pet portraits more heavily, an angle less seen among competitors.
Positioning Recommendation: John should position himself as the go-to artist for whimsical NYC-inspired art and personalized pet portraits, leveraging his local connections and community involvement to stand out.
Expected Impact
If recommendations are implemented:
Discoverability:
- Estimated increase in profile visits: 15-25%
- Improved search ranking for keywords: "NYC Artist," "Pet Portraits"
Conversion:
- Estimated increase in inquiry rate: 20-30%
- Better lead qualification through highlights/bio clarity
Professionalism:
- Profile confidence score: 7.5/10 → 9/10 after improvements
Final Recommendations
What's Working (Keep Doing):
✅ Strong engagement with local community events and markets
✅ Consistent posting schedule maintaining audience interest
✅ Unique combination of NYC themes and pet portraits
What Needs Fixing (Priority):
❌ Overly cluttered highlight section
❌ Undefined business category limiting discoverability
❌ Lack of specific social proof in bio
Biggest Opportunity: John can capitalize on his NYC positioning and pet artistry to create a compelling brand story. By refining his bio and highlight strategy, he can significantly increase engagement and conversion rates, potentially boosting follower growth by 25% and inquiries by 30%.
Positioning Statement: "Johnnerdraws: Bringing whimsical NYC-inspired art and personalized pet portraits to life—supporting local creativity and community."
Next Steps
CRITICAL: This section is MANDATORY. Provide a clear, numbered action plan for the next 30 days:
- Update Bio and FullName (Immediate) - Enhance discoverability and clarity in the brand message.
- Optimize Highlight Reels (1 week) - Reduce to 5-10 core categories to improve user navigation.
- Refine Linktree Titles (1 week) - Use clear, actionable text for each link to increase click-through rates.
- Implement UTM Tracking (2 weeks) - Gain insights into traffic sources and optimize marketing strategies.
- Engagement Analysis (2 weeks) - Review post performance and audience interaction to refine content strategy.
- Community Engagement (1 month) - Increase participation in local events and collaborations for visibility.
Expected Result: By implementing these recommendations, John should experience a 15-25% increase in profile visits and a 20-30% boost in inquiries, significantly enhancing both his online presence and business opportunities.
Have questions about your audit? (Or anything else marketing related?)
Ask them live. A free Zoom session for artists and photographers — Monday, Wednesday & Friday at 3pm CT. Real questions, real answers.
Get My Questions Answered →